Battle of Exams

Battle of Exams

“The toughest battle you’ll ever fight in your life is the battle within yourself.” – Anonymous

An exam toughness is subjective, it may be difficult to quantify. Any opinion based on past feedback may not be valid for future exams. We try to compare three popular exams – NEET, JEE and KCET using some past data. Please take this analysis with a pinch of salt!

Toughness parameters

Let us assume, the toughness of any competitive exam is going to depend upon following two factors:

1. Competitiveness – Number of applicants v/s available seats,

2. Difficulty level –

         a. Quality of questions,

         b. Average time available for solving a question.

Competitiveness

The table below shows three exams and number of applicants. This data has been taken from on-line news portals or blogs. These figures are for the year 2016 – 2017, may not be accurate.

The last column is a ratio of 2nd and 3rd column values,

Competitiveness = Number of applicants / available seats.

Exams No of applicants (approx) Available seats Competitiveness
JEE 12 lakh 18,000 66.67
NEET 11 lakh 25,000 44.00
KCET 1.50 lakh 83,000 1.81

Surely JEE is more competitive than NEET, there are more applicants per available seat.

Difficulty level

The quality of questions can be low, moderate or high and can be subjective.

The difficulty level of any exam will be such that an applicant should be able to attend all questions in an allocated time. This is how all the boards or examination authorities would set the question papers. Hence, we can use average time allocated for a question as an indicator of difficulty level.

Difficulty level = Average time allocated to solve a question.

The table below shows maximum duration, number of questions and difficulty level.

Exams Duration (in minutes) No of questions Difficulty level (Average time in minutes)
JEE 180 90 2.0
NEET 180 180 1.0
KCET 180 180 1.0

As we can see, only JEE Mains allocates 2 minutes for a question and the difficulty level is considered to be highest among all exams.

The difficulty level of NEET and KCET are moderate based on quality of questions.

The JEE and NEET are somewhere in between high and moderate, in a difficulty scale.

Toughness Index

We now want to combine difficulty level and competitiveness to compute a toughness index. The assumption is – a higher difficulty level will weed out poorly prepared or less serious applicants, and hence may reduce the competitiveness.

Hope this is not contradicting any proven theory.

Toughness Index = (Competitiveness +- x ) / ( Difficulty level +- y),

x and y are correction factors to address any errors (or bias) in our assumptions. Let us neglect x and y; x = 0, y = 0,

Toughness Index = Competitiveness / Difficulty level.

Exams Competitiveness Difficulty level Toughness Index
NEET 44.00 1.0 44.00
JEE 66.67 2.0 33.34
KCET 1.81 1.0 1.81

It does look like NEET is tougher than JEE.

 

Note: We answered a question on Quora where MHCET and GUJCET have also been compared:  

How tough is the GUJCET compared to the MH CET (engineering)?